For job-seekers, there can be a huge sense of disappointment after an interview goes well but you are rejected from the role. You’ve put in the work to prepare for the meeting, you felt like you had a great rapport with the hiring manager – so why did that result in a no?
There are often situations where an individual receives feedback that is difficult to understand from the outside looking in, so understanding why this scenario happens is important when considering positive steps to take for future interviews.
Ultimately, knowing what may have gone wrong and how to go about improving in future job applications can help boost your confidence as you continue applying and interviewing for jobs.
There are many reasons why your interview went well yet you got rejected; these include everything from not fulfilling certain criteria laid out by employers, lack of experience with the skills needed for the role, and more.
Beyond that, it could simply be that there were other key factors at play such as soft skills which someone else had more than you, making them a better fit. Considering all of this as part of your post-interview reflection can lead to greater success moving forward.
1. Company culture
A company’s culture determines what kind of environment employees are working in, and it is essential to make sure that your own values align with the company’s before applying for a job. Even if you demonstrate great skills in an interview, your personality or professional values might not be compatible with the organisation's work style and you won't be considered a good fit.
To ensure that the hiring manager senses your enthusiasm about the company's culture during interviews, it is recommended to do some research beforehand. Browsing through their website will provide insight into how they operate and allow you to give convincing examples of how you can become a core part of their team.
Additionally, being able to discuss specifically how your background has prepared you for success at this particular organisation is a great way to show off your knowledge and commitment to fitting in with their culture.
2. Applicant competition
Competition among applicants is a reality of the job search process. While you may have put in hours preparing for your interview, been confident throughout the entire process, and feel like you've earned the role – other contenders may have qualifications or skills that are slightly more desirable.
Recognising this can help you remain hopeful when faced with hearing that someone else has been selected for a particular position.
It's never an easy realisation to accept, but there are typically multiple people interviewing for positions within any given field. To improve your chances of getting hired next time–you could diversify your skill set or expand your experience in order to make yourself stand out from the competition.
Who knows, the hiring manager might be so impressed by you during the interview process they might even keep your contact information handy and reach out should another opportunity arise down the road!
3. Communication
One of the most important aspects of communication during the job search process is responding to messages in a timely manner. Even if you’ve impressed your potential employer with an amazing interview, if they struggle to reach out to you about a job offer or seek additional information regarding your application, it doesn’t matter how brilliant the performance was. .
Waiting days or weeks to respond may reflect poorly on your professionalism as a candidate, so it’s essential for you to remain engaged until after an offer is either accepted or rejected. All of the details count in terms of getting hired - not just your qualifications and experience level - so make sure all communication sent and received remains professional in tone and quick enough that any opportunity isn’t lost due to lack of response.
This will help ensure your potential employer has the best possible impression of you throughout the entire application process.
4. Gaps in skills and knowledge
When it comes to applying for a new job, potential employers need to know that you have the necessary skills and knowledge to do the work they are looking for. Unfortunately, in some cases there can be a disconnect between the qualifications outlined in your CV and your actual abilities or understanding of the topics.
You need to know how best to highlight and communicate your relevant experiences, expanding on what is already in your CV.
Additionally, if there are areas where there may be gaps it’s always worth mentioning them when submitting an application, as well as providing examples on how you plan on overcoming them, rather than trying to blag it in the interview. Showing enthusiasm and confidence in yourself will help paint a better picture of who you are beyond just what appears on paper.
5. Professional boundaries
Professional boundaries are essential in any professional setting. When it comes to job interviews, it's particularly important not to overstep these boundaries and maintain a certain level of professionalism throughout. An interviewer needs to focus on your skills that make you the best candidate for the job. Going into personal details can be counterproductive; it may send a signal that you lack the necessary discipline and poise required for the role you are applying for.
Moreover, spending too much time discussing personal matters can also lead to an uncomfortable atmosphere which could derail the entire process. It should not be viewed as casual conversation between two individuals, but rather as an opportunity for you to showcase yourself and shine above your competition. Demonstrating restraint during interviews will help hiring managers notice your ability to conduct yourself in a professional manner. Taking ownership of this responsibility and maintaining sound judgement will steer any interview away from inappropriate topics or conversations while still remaining courteous and pleasant.
Tips for improving your interview skills:
If you don’t land a role after what initially seemed like a successful meeting with the hiring party–it’s not necessarily over. You can still take steps in order to gain valuable feedback and incorporate it into future job searches.
Make sure to ask for constructive feedback directly from the hiring manager or employer; they may be able to offer suggestions from their perspective which could make all the difference when attempting to create an even better showing next time.
Apart from simply asking for advice, make sure to rehearse your answers ahead of time too; having mock dialogue with yourself on topics common among the position may help you stand out and answer confidently during an actual interview situation.
Additionally, do your best to boost your self-confidence before heading into an interview room; believing in yourself and your qualifications is equally as important as preparing beforehand.
Put in some extra effort both mentally and physically leading up an upcoming job interview, and those improvements will show for themselves in due time!
Looking for a new role?
If you're looking for a new role within IT Business Change & Transformation or Workplace Change/Space Planning then get in touch with an up to date copy of your CV.
Alternatively, click here to view our jobs page to browse our current vacancies.